successful fry, dying parents

Welcome to the website! Forums The Celestial Pearl Danio Breeding successful fry, dying parents

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #10571
    zmo63
    Participant

    Hi, I’m a new member, but I’ve been reading this forum for a long time, and it’s been very helpful. This is the first time I’ve had a question that wasn’t already answered, so I hope you all can give me some advice.

    The short version is: Has anyone had their adults stop eating and waste away after the fry are hatched?

    Here’s the whole story:

    I’ve had four CPDs for nearly a year. Three females, one male. They’re in a heavily planted 10 gallon, which they share with 4 otocinclus. About six months ago, I started feeding a higher percentage of frozen foods versus flake/micropellets, to try to condition them for breeding. I’ve been alternating bloodworms, mysis shrimp, cyclops worms, along with a variety of freeze dried, flake, and pellet foods.

    It worked! After a couple of months of finding a single fry here and there (which would disappear the next day), I set up a net breeder in the tank, and started scooping out babies and putting them in the net. I got 40 fry, and now, 4 weeks on, there are over 20 left.

    Since the babies were outgrowing the net breeder, I decided to set up a separate tank two weeks ago. I hedged my bets by putting 10 fry back in with the parents, and put the rest in a barebottom Q tank. Both sets of fry are doing well, but the ones in the parents’ tank seem to be growing faster. There are at least six still alive in there.

    So here’s the problem: Since the first fry in this batch appeared, the parents have stopped coming out to eat. They’re always shy, but they used to patrol the tank each morning when the lights come on, and come out to feed each evening (until the fry, I was feeding once a day).

    I thought that since I was feeding so much fry food, maybe enough was getting into their hiding place (behind the driftwood, out of sight), that they just didn’t need to come out to eat.

    One week ago, I came home to a dead oto and a dying female CPD. I took her out and quarantined, but she died overnight. She had been listless, swimming at the top, and slightly tilted.

    ammonia 0, nitrite 0, nitrates ~20. I still assumed it was a water quality thing, since I’d been overfeeding to get them in breeding condition, and over feeding to keep the fry fed. The tank was admittedly, a mess – algae, snails, and crud everywhere. I did a 20% water change that night, and another 20% the next day. I used a different test kit, but ammonia and nitrite still read at 0.

    I did a large water change on Sunday (>50%). Tuesday, my only male was dead.

    Yesterday (wednesday), the remaining two females were swimming about and they didn’t look good. They’re very skinny, very pale, and kind of listless. Since they were out, I tried to entice them to eat brine shrimp and micropellets soaked in garlic. I don’t think they went for it.

    Meanwhile, the fry are doing great! If it were a water quality problem or a disease, wouldn’t they be the first to die? It really seems like they’re starving themselves to death.

    I think these guys were wild caught. Their colors were stunning, and I’m crushed that I’m losing them. I didn’t treat for parasites when I bought them, so now I’m doing a couple of rounds of levamisole – one is completed, two more to go.

    Background on me – my husband and I have been keeping fish for three years, and have several planted tanks (mostly devoted to loaches and other SE Asian fish). This is my first attempt at breeding.

    and for wading through all that text, here’s a picture. The net is no longer there, since the babies outgrew it.

    Thanks for any help!

    #13621
    tedr108
    Participant

    That’s a shame, zmo.

    Logically, it really sounds like a water quality issue. But, then again, as you say, why aren’t the fry dying?

    I’ve only been keeping fish for 6 months, so I may be way off, but…

    Your tank sounds and looks like it is overgrown. I’m wondering if that isn’t hurting your tank’s circulation. Perhaps the fry are hanging out in a good part of the tank and the others are in a no-circulation area. Just a thought … it may not really make much sense. It is just something that I would look into. You could either get an extra cheapo HOB filter and get some more circulation going or do some pruning. My guess is that sooner or later the fry will be hurting also.

    #13622
    zmo63
    Participant

    That’s an interesting idea – not one I’d thought of. I have let it become very overgrown – been trying to keep my hands out of it as much as possible with the fry in there.

    The adults hang out right by the filter (aquaclear 30), and the babies hover above them in the same general area.

    I’ll do some trimming tonight and maybe reposition some of the driftwood to get some more flow in the rest of the tank. Even if it’s not the culprit, it’s a good idea.

    #13626
    altaaffe
    Participant

    Hi zmo,

    Sorry to hear your problems. You said that you changed their food for breeding, did you change back again after the fry. I use live, frozen & flake for mine but the wild specimens tend to bulk up on the live and just nibble enough of the others to keep going. That fact that an Otto died at the same time is a concern though.

    I had a CO2 regulator fail on me and dumped a whole 2kg bottle into the water stream, fortunately with a quick rescue act all fish & shrimp survived but for a single otto. Have you checked your CO2 level, pH, etc. Big swings could be affecting them as well.

    #13627
    zmo63
    Participant

    I didn’t change their food after the fry appeared – just used hikari first bites powder in addition to the parents’ food. Actually, the first death occurred the same day I started feeding live baby brine shrimp. I wonder if that’s significant? I was feeding all the tanks the same bbs, so I don’t think it could have been a bad batch.

    The pH has stayed constant at 7 – same as it comes out of the tap. I haven’t checked the gH or kH, but we have very soft water. No CO2 in the tank. I had been dosing Flourish and Flourish Excel, but stopped at the first sight of fry.

    I didn’t condition the adults on live food, but once i started feeding a lot of frozen, I saw a big difference in their color, and they really bulked up. Never had a problem with them turning down any food though – as long as it was small enough to fit in their mouths ;)

    #13632
    katkin
    Participant

    Just a thought, but could it have been old age? Does anyone know yet how long these guys live for? It may have just been coincidence that you also lost an otto.
    I f you are not sure how old the adults were when you first got them, they may be older than you think.
    K

    #13635
    zmo63
    Participant

    Hi katkin, you’re right, I definitely don’t know how old they are. I’ve had them for just under a year, and they were in the store a long time before that. They were wanting $25 per fish, but after many months and a lot of employee turnover (chain store), I took the whole lot of them for $4. Seven originally, but three died in quarantine.

    Old age is definitely not out of the question – I just didn’t want to jump to that conclusion if there were anything wrong in the tank that I could correct. If thats it though, I’d still think it strange that they declined so rapidly after spawning. Maybe it just took a lot out of them?

    In an odd way, it’s kind of encouraging that no one has an obvious answer – I’d like to think it means I’m getting to be a better fish keeper.

    I did remove some driftwood, and did a lot of pruning. I’m also doing 10-15% water changes every other day. The two remaining females are appearing on occasion, but I have yet to see them eat. They’re still very skinny.

    I’ll continue with two more rounds of levamisole, and report back if there’s any improvement. Fry are still growing, so that’s some consolation!

    thanks everyone – feel free to jump in if anyone has more ideas.

    #14386
    hdthan
    Participant

    I read somewhere that the capsules from bbs cysts can sometimes get lodged inside the digestive tract of fry, and small fish, killing them. If you’re feeding live bbs, and hatching them yourself, maybe this is something to consider. I’m not sure if you do, but just my two cents.

    #14387
    ged
    Participant

    @hdthan wrote:

    I read somewhere that the capsules from bbs cysts can sometimes get lodged inside the digestive tract of fry, and small fish, killing them. If you’re feeding live bbs, and hatching them yourself, maybe this is something to consider. I’m not sure if you do, but just my two cents.

    I have read about the casings as well.

    A couple of questions
    How long do leave your lights on?
    How long has the tank been set up?
    They are a very timid fish especially wild caught, it would actually concern me more if they were in the open under the filter rather than hiding, but still why is the question, maybe an o2 problem? Maybe shock? if you stopped fertilizing all at once I would just cut the ferts in half instead of completely stopping. I think any rapid change can adversely effect fish.

    Water quality as was said before would be ones first reaction, it is unusual and if the otto hadn’t died first I would say it were age. I have had them for almost 4 years and found them to be most resilient to bacteria and fungus even when other fish were infected in the same tank. They are sensitive to disturbance in their environment i.e sudden movement or light shock as well.

    #14388
    Tom2006
    Participant

    guys this thread is two years old. :wink:

    #14389
    ged
    Participant

    Haha….I just noticed the date of the previous response not the original date.

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.